Macau’s Tourism Transformation: Luxury Brands Left Behind?

Macau’s visitor numbers are surging, bolstering the city’s status as an important destination for Greater Bay Area travelers. Official data showed that Macau saw a record-breaking day this past Saturday, with a total of 197,000 visitors entering the city.

This brought overall visitors in 2024 to over 20 million, with average daily visitors climbing to 93,000 – 36% higher than during the same period in 2023 and 83% of pre-pandemic levels.

The Macau Government Tourism Office recently set a target of 33 million visitors for 2024, a number the SAR is likely to achieve by year’s end. This compares to the 28 million visitors Macau welcomed in 2023, and over 39 million visitors the city recorded at peak levels in 2019.

Policy payoff #

Macau’s growing number of visitors can be directly attributed to July’s increase in duty-free shopping allowances for Chinese visitors, with both Macau and Hong Kong setting new total limits of 15,000 RMB ($2,090).

Broken down, that comprises 12,000 RMB ($1,670) for luggage-carry items, more than double the previous limit of 5,000 RMB ($695), while the additional 3,000 RMB ($418) is reserved for purchases at duty-free stores at border locations.

The city’s pivot towards the broader tourist market follows China’s capital control measures limiting high-stakes gamblers and more recently, the country’s criminalization of illegal money-changing activities, which allowed Chinese players to circumvent the controls.

In addition, Macau’s increased tourism is also linked to the recent Hengqin-Macau multiple-entry policy, introduced in May. Under the policy, mainland Chinese tour groups are issued a special visa that allows them to make multiple trips into Macau through the city’s neighboring island of Hengqin.

Diversification beckons #

A pivot to more entertainment, family-friendly activities, F&B as well as cultural highlights and events has garnered more interest from a wider range of tourists, including families, to the casino hotspot. Macau’s Chief Executive Ho lat Seng announced that the city’s new measures “will contribute to consolidating Macau’s role as a global tourism and leisure center and creating more advantageous conditions for the development of adequate diversification of the economy.”

Despite rising visitor numbers and efforts to attract Chinese tourists, Macau’s luxury retail shops continue to decline. Retailers interviewed across clothing, watches, jewelry, cosmetics, and other segments all saw 30% to 50% YoY sales drops in April. Experts chalk up the numbers to changing consumption patterns.

“The luxury retail shops in Macau are targeting mainland Chinese, and more and more of these duty-free shops opening in recent years will make Macau less attractive,” Nelson Kot, president of the Macau Comprehensive Social Research Association, is reported as saying when addressing the “reshaping” consumption patterns of Chinese travelers.

Brands still have an opportunity to engage high-spending Chinese tourists in Macau, but as the landscape becomes more competitive, they will have to up the ante on activations, pop-ups and shopping-as-entertainment experiences to engage consumers. As many Chinese reallocate their leisure spending to experiential purchases such as travel, over buying just luxury goods, the question remains whether cities like Macau (and Hong Kong) can capitalize on their offerings for both.

Seizing Opportunities: A Look at China’s Recent Changes

1. Adapting to the new trend? National tourism bureaus are getting on board with Xiaohongshu and Podcasts

  • Australia’s 618 Campaign:

    • The Australia tourism bureau partnered with Xiaohongshu for “Just Rush to Australia on 618,” involving 40 travel brands and offering various travel packages.

  • Dubai’s Summer Campaign:

    • Dubai tourism bureau launched “Dubai can also play like this” activities, inviting travel influencers and partnering with local businesses to offer discounts and prizes.

  • Singapore’s Theatre Campaign:

    • Following a visa exemption policy, Singapore’s tourism bureau and Xiaohongshu launched “Theatre in Singapore,” featuring an interactive online page and an offline experience space in Shanghai.

  • New Zealand’s Xiaohongshu Partnership:

    • New Zealand’s tourism bureau partnered with Xiaohongshu to engage its 260 million monthly users, aiming to attract tourists and boost economic growth.

  • Podcast Collaborations:

    • Tourism bureaus from Spain, Singapore, New Zealand, and South Africa collaborated with Xiaoyuzhou podcasts to promote travel, including Dubai’s podcast series “Dubai Mysteries.”

2. China leads the way as social commerce soars globally: McKinsey

  • According to McKinsey & Company’s “State of the Consumer 2024: What’s New and What’s Next” report, China has been at the forefront of this trend for several years, with its market outpacing India’s. Emerging markets such as Brazil, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE are rapidly catching up, with consumers in these regions consistently spending more on social media purchases compared to their counterparts in Europe and the US.

  • McKinsey forecasts that the market will expand to $145 billion by 2027, up from $67 billion today. This growth is primarily driven by Gen Z and millennials, who are four times more likely to make social media purchases than older generations. Over one-third of Gen Z and millennial respondents reported purchasing on social media in the past three months, underscoring the demographic’s pivotal role in driving this trend.

Link:https://jingdaily.com/posts/china-leads-the-way-as-social-commerce-soars-globally-mckinsey

3. Xiao Hongshu Presents at VOGUE Business New York Beauty Summit

Xiaohongshu was invited to the “VOGUE Business New York Beauty Summit” in NYC. More than one hundred beauty brand founders, top managers and industry experts attended the venue to dissect the latest trends in the beauty and personal care industry and discuss the development trajectory of this industry.

  •  As consumer desires for self-care evolve further, the domestic beauty and hair care market is transitioning from basic functional aspirations to a more diverse and specialized era.

  • Within Xiaohongshu’s 300 million monthly active users, 50% are Generation Z (born in the ‘90s), 35% are Post-Millennials (born after 2000), and 50% reside in Tier 1 and 2 cities.

  •  “Beauty Enhancement”, an array of lifestyle activities aimed at beautification, has been pinpointed by Xiaohongshu as being driven by four core elements: “inner drive, personal charm, socializing, and influence”.

  • Brands can leverage influencer live broadcasts, store broadcasts, and product related posts, to accelerate the process from user interest to conversion, resulting in direct sales and conversions.

  • Employing KOS, the brands can forge a connection with potential fan base. Deliver specialized content and endorsements to users. Channel online high potential groups to offline stores to experience skin care, sample distribution, gift giving, etc., and complete the offline conversion process. This can also accelerate user purchase decisions.

Link: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/7cdCqkwPz_Sg5UbPF5sw-A

 

4. WeChat Officially Launches the ‘One-click AI Q&A’ Feature

  • Users of WeChat can now leverage the power of AI directly within the chat thanks to the new “One-click AI Q&A” feature integrated into the app’s input method.

  • Users can ask questions followed by an “=” sign within the chat, and the AI will provide an answer. This functionality is currently available on Windows and Mac versions of WeChat, with the mobile version set to launch soon.

  • In addition to the new AI feature, the WeChat input method boasts other helpful tools to enhance communication.

Link: https://pandaily.com/wechat-officially-launches-the-one-click-ai-qa-feature/

 

5. 15-year-old Bilibili and its three generations of young audiences

  • On 27 June, Bilibili, China’s equivalent of YouTube, celebrated its 15th anniversary. Chairman and CEO Chen Rui delivered a speech themed “Growing with You” during the anniversary livestream.

  • Bilibili’s user base is dominated by those born in the 1990s and 2000s, accounting for nearly 70% of the total. Currently, the platform boasts 102 million daily active users and 341 million monthly active users, with the average daily usage time being 105 minutes.

  • Users who joined in 2017 have more diversified entertainment preferences, including anime, national creativity, documentaries, and science and technology content. And those who joined in 2022 primarily consume various university courses.

  • Data from Bilibili also shows that over 70 million users research cars on the platform every month, with a 218% year-on-year increase in contributions.

  • Since its inception in 2009, Bilibili has evolved from an early Erciyuan cultural community into a multicultural platform encompassing over 7,000 interest circles.

Link: https://daoinsights.com/news/15-year-old-bilibili-and-its-three-generations-of-young-audiences/

Identifying Opportunities: Delving into China’s Latest Updates

1.Beijing asks Tencent to lower WeChat’s mobile payment market share

  • Tencent Holdings has been asked by China’s regulators to lower the mobile payment market share of its WeChat app. The directive is aimed more at the market share for in-person payments made by scanning QR codes than for online shopping.

  • It is not clear whether Tencent was given any precise numerical target to meet, but one person familiar with the situation said, “WeChat is not targeting user expansion, and it is very cautious about the potential risks of growing too big.

  • China’s mobile payment market is dominated by two players, WeChat Pay and Alipay, even though there are around 185 non-bank payment institutions in the world’s largest cashless society.

  • WeChat is ahead of Alipay in terms of market share by a ratio of around 3:2. In terms of the number of transactions, WeChat has an even higher share, as there are more small-value transactions on the app.

  • WeChat has a smaller marketing team than Alipay and has been offering fewer payment discounts than it once did, but the all-in-one app remains extremely popular throughout the country. It has reached even older users in remote areas, who tend not to have Alipay accounts and who regularly use WeChat to chat and shop. WeChat has 1.36 billion monthly active users.

Link: https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Technology/Beijing-asks-Tencent-to-lower-WeChat-s-mobile-payment-market-share

2. Scratch card effect? Young people find solace in instant lottery as cards sell out

  • Luxury fashion brands in China are going beyond just physical stores. They are creating a more well-rounded approach that considers both cultural integration and technological advancements in e-commerce.

  • This strategy combines partnerships with Chinese cultural institutions, like art museums, with a strong focus on e-commerce.

    • Luxury brands are partnering with Chinese art institutions: The article mentions Chanel’s collaboration with the Power Station of Art museum to cultivate a stronger association with art and culture in China.

    • E-commerce is a major focus: LVMH, a giant luxury fashion group, is partnering with Alibaba Cloud to leverage their cloud solutions and artificial intelligence for an enhanced e-commerce experience in China. This includes improving their omnichannel presence, data collection, and overall tech infrastructure.

Link: https://jingdaily.com/posts/from-museums-to-e-commerce-luxury-fashion-s-multi-pronged-approach-to-china

 

3. Dairy brand Yili unveils two new low carbon milk products, furthering sustainability commitment

  • Innovative Product Development: Yili introduced low-carbon milk products utilizing feed technology that cuts methane emissions by up to 30%.

  • Sustainable Packaging: They’ve adopted reduced aluminum foil and ink in packaging, significantly lowering the products’ carbon footprint.

  • Youth Engagement: Yili targets youth with environmentally friendly products to instill sustainable habits early.

  • Comprehensive Sustainability Goals: The ‘WISH 2030’ system outlines Yili’s decade-long commitment to sustainable development.

  • Global and Local Integration: Yili operates with a global reach yet ensures local adaptation in its sustainability practices.

Link:https://daoinsights.com/news/dairy-brand-yili-unveils-two-new-low-carbon-milk-products-furthering-sustainability-commitment/

4. Is ‘20 minute parks’ China’s version of forest bathing?

  • Chinese youth are seeking rejuvenation and spiritual healing in parks, with the hashtag “20-minute park effect” gaining over 131 million views on Xiaohongshu.

  • China aims to expand the number of urban green spaces, with Shanghai planning to open about 200 parks in the next year.

  • Many young Chinese report that spending time in parks improves their mood and overall well-being, reflecting a shift towards slower living amid intense work conditions.

  • Brands can leverage the popularity of parks to engage with consumers in a relaxed, spacious environment, which can positively influence perceptions of the brand.

  • Beyond hosting activities and pop-ups in parks, brands should center their messaging around Chinese consumers’ desire for quiet, wellness, and a reconnection to nature, as evidenced during the May Day holidays.

Link: https://jingdaily.com/posts/is-20-minute-parks-china-s-version-of-forest-bathing

 

5. Goodbye facekinis: Trendy sun protection takes over China

  • By 2026, the sun protection apparel market is expected to reach a value of approximately 100 billion RMB ($13.8 billion), fueled by rising skin health awareness and increased participation in outdoor sports.

  • There is a notable shift in consumer preferences towards sun protective clothing that is not only functional but also stylish, influenced by Chinese brands like Bosideng and online fashion trends.

  • Although Chinese brands are quicker at adapting to consumer trends, global brands like Nike and Uniqlo have opportunities to compete in the Chinese market by leveraging technological innovation and unique product designs.

  • Emphasizing the versatility and convenience of sun protective clothing compared to sunscreen (e.g., no need for reapplication, less skin irritation) can appeal to active consumers engaged in outdoor activities like hiking and camping.

Link: https://jingdaily.com/posts/china-sun-protection-wear-trends-2024

6. Xiaohongshu: the Citywalk trend is still vibrant

“Urban trip” related content got 240% growth on Xiaohongshu, around 3 million posts were related to Citywalk last year. This year, we have “溜溜生活”,  which means your life is like a citywalk.

  •  Xiaohognshu brought this topic from online to offline. They invited diverse category brands and created an instant pop-up bazaar with food and art in Guangzhou.

  • Over 2 billion exposure were generated during the event, and the clicks on this topic exceeded 300 million. Their offline bazaar got more than 50,000 visitors in 3 days.

  • Major brands are tapping into it and engaging with the younger generation to unlock growth opportunities.

  • It would be nice to seize the opportunity and make the brands involved in the trend in order to get more exposure and raise awareness.

Link: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/eNjtWLcMVDcCErqWZoanlw

 

7. Young Chinese Have Almost No Concerns About AI, Survey Finds

  • China’s younger generations appear to be embracing generative AI with few reservations, according to the report by the research institute.

  • According to the report, the top reason young Chinese cite for favoring generative AI is its ability to improve their work efficiency.

  • Young Chinese hold overwhelmingly positive attitudes toward the rise of generative artificial intelligence and are mostly concerned about how to profit from the new technology

  • People said that AI bots made good conversation partners because they didn’t make them feel awkward, responded quickly, and were willing to chat about anything.

Link: https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1015263

 

8. Balenciaga Spring 2025 Collection host on May 30, 2024, Shanghai created buzz

  • Balenciaga’s Spring 2025 show in Shanghai highlights the brand’s strategic focus on China, a crucial market known for its strong support of the brand.

  • The runway in the sudden rain created buzz in Chinese social media platforms.

  • The Shanghai show celebrated the brand’s couture offerings with 10 gowns crafted just for this event, generating significant social buzz.

  • Innovative collaborations with Alipay and a famed local restaurant nods to a robust localization strategy.

Link:https://jingdaily.com/posts/demna-s-vision-shines-at-balenciaga-s-shanghai-runway#701bdb9eeee3

Uncovering Opportunities: Exploring Recent Developments in China

1.”Domestic pride”: growing preferences for domestically made products

  • Among the top 10 most popular movies in 2024 so far, only one is a foreign movie (Godzilla vs. Kong).
  • The topics related to “intangible cultural heritage” have been trending up on social media platforms, with many netizens discussing China’s traditional craftsmanship, art, and artisan designs.
  • The growing preferences for domestically made products are influencing the business environment and marketing strategies of merchants. Many historic and cultural institutions, such as the Forbidden City Palace and local museums, are introducing their own creative products.
  • Various international luxury giants like LVMH are integrating Chinese elements into their product designs to attract Chinese consumers, and “intangible cultural heritage” is just becoming the new localization strategy of these international brands.
  • Even if a business does not directly sell intangible cultural heritage products, they are leveraging its popularity for its own marketing strategies. For instance, Chinese retail chain MINISO ran a marketing campaign where consumers could experience writing the 江永女书 (Jiangyong Women’s Script) in their offline retail stores. The successful marketing campaign combined two elements that have become very popular in China’s consumer markets in recent years: “women empowerment” and “intangible cultural heritage.”

Link: https://www.baiguan.news/p/chinese-consumers-real-estate-market-job-trend

 

2. Is luxury missing out on China’s cycling boom?

  • China is historically known as the “kingdom of bicycles,” with young people carrying on the movement as streetwear infiltrates the space and brands amp up the elegance of their offerings to cater to this new more fashion-conscious demographic.
  • On Xiaohongshu, the hashtag “my cycling log” (#我的騎乘日誌) takes you to 1.17 billion photos, starring millions of outfit posts by Gen Z cycling fanatics.
  • While specialized brands thrive, luxury houses should look to the space for collaboration opportunities, whether through ambassador partnerships with established domestic cyclists or clothing capsules to cater to the major trend in China.
  • For brands looking to enter new markets like China, leveraging existing fanbases, as seen with Rapha’s recent entry, can instill confidence; however, ensuring long-term success requires strategic planning for maintaining engagement and relevance

Link: https://jingdaily.com/posts/chinese-streetwear-s-biggest-craze-cycling

3. What is the “twenty minutes in the park” theory? Brands are holding outdoor activities to connect with consumers

 

  • As more and more young people flock to parks, brands are following suit to find new marketing opportunities.
  • Young people who are overwhelmed by reality and can’t catch their breath find spiritual healing in the park.
  • From 22 March to 22 April, Xiaohongshu partnered with Nanjing’s Xuanwu Lake Park to launch the “Hanging out in the park matters a lot” (逛公园才是正经事) campaign, inviting Nanjing residents to spend time in the park.
  • In addition to sports and camping, mart brand plant b’s “Urban Forest Project” was held in mid-April this year at the Great Lawn of Hangzhou Botanical Garden’s Botanical Area, inviting more than 100 brands to participate.
  • In many cases, purchases are based on emotional judgement, especially when consumers are feeling relaxed, and a natural product placement is more likely to receive positive feedback.

Link: https://daoinsights.com/works/what-is-the-twenty-minutes-in-the-park-theory-brands-are-holding-outdoor-activities-to-connect-with-consumers/

4. Scratch card effect? Young people find solace in instant lottery as cards sell out

  • Scratch cards have seen a significant rise in popularity among young people in China, transforming from a pastime of older generations to a social activity embraced by the younger demographic. This surge is fueled by influencers on social media platforms like Weibo and creative uses of scratch cards in livestreams and DIY prize draws.
  • The appeal of scratch cards lies in their instant nature, providing immediate results and gratification. This aspect has made scratch cards a popular social activity, even being incorporated into venues like coffee shops. High-profile wins, such as a young person winning 1 million RMB, have further amplified interest and engagement on social media.
  • Despite the skyrocketing demand, the supply of scratch cards is limited due to strict regulation and a slow production turnaround. This has led to widespread shortages, with shop owners struggling to restock. The Ministry of Finance’s data shows a dramatic increase in sales, yet the supply chain is unable to keep pace, leading to empty shelves and a competitive restocking process.

Link: https://daoinsights.com/opinions/scratch-card-effect-young-people-find-solace-in-instant-lottery-as-cards-sell-out/ 

 

5. Weibo, Douyin, Xiaohongshu remove displays of wealth

  • Influencers Wang Hongquanxing, Baoyujiejie, and Baigongzi had their accounts banned across all platforms on May 21st.
  • These influencers were known for showcasing luxury items and boasting about their wealth to attract attention and drive sales through live-streaming e-commerce.
  • The bans are part of a government campaign to clean up online content that promotes materialism and unhealthy values.
  • Such displays of wealth can exacerbate social inequality and negatively influence youth.
  • The situation highlights the need for better content moderation and stricter platform policies to foster a healthier online environment.
  • From a luxury brand point of view, perceived value on the secondhand market can have direct repercussions on reputation and desirability in the eyes of consumers.

Link: https://jingdaily.com/posts/chinese-social-media-remove-displays-of-wealth 

Discovering Opportunities: Exploring China’s Recent Updates

1. Shanghai takes the lead as Chinese coffee consumption averages 16 cups per year

  • China’s coffee industry amassed a staggering 265.4 billion RMB (approx. 36.66 billion USD) in scale last year, with an average per capita annual consumption of 16.74 cups
  • Coffee Carnival is running in Shanghai between 30 April to 4 May, alongside over 50 esteemed local coffee shops.
  • Additionally, takeaway, payment, and social media platforms initiated the “Drinking in the City” campaign in Shanghai, poised to invest nearly 100 million RMB (approx. 13.8 million USD) into the consumer market.
  • With a net increase of 118 shops, marking a 14% year-on-year rise, the total count of Starbucks outlets soared to 7,093.

LINK:https://daoinsights.com/news/shanghai-takes-the-lead-as-chinese-coffee-consumption-averages-16-cups-per-year/

2.What’s driving China’s unstoppable second hand luxury market?

  • China’s secondhand luxury market is tipped to grow to $30 billion (217 billion RMB) in 2025 from $8 billion (58 billion RMB) in 2020, with Gen Z and millennials (under 40) together accounting for more than 80 percent of the total number of secondhand luxury consumers
  • From a luxury brand point of view, perceived value on the secondhand market can have direct repercussions on reputation and desirability in the eyes of consumers.
  • Brands should not see the secondhand market as an adverse phenomenon, but encourage customers to trade in or resell their pre-owned items through authorized channels, ensuring that the brand retains control over the quality and authenticity of the products in the secondary market.
  • Luxury brands must monitor and manage their perceived value in the secondhand market, as it can impact their reputation and desirability among consumers. Digital marketing efforts should focus on maintaining brand authenticity and highlighting the enduring quality and heritage of their products.

LINK:https://jingdaily.com/posts/what-s-driving-china-s-unstoppable-secondhand-luxury-market#8548723daa5e

3. Decoding China’s $170 billion ‘romance economy’

  • China commemorates love on three separate holidays: the Western Valentine’s Day on February 14, the uniquely Chinese 520 Day on May 20, a celebration derived from internet slang where the numbers “520” phonetically resemble the words for “I love you” in Mandarin, and the traditional Qixi Festival, which usually falls in August.
  • China’s Gen Z consumers are a key element of the “romance economy,” responsible for 54% of related orders according to the “Romantic Economic Big Data Report” released in 2022.
  • Survey data from iiMedia Research in 2023 revealed that regardless of their relationship status – single, in a relationship, or married – over 90% of participants were eager to celebrate romantic festivals by presenting gifts to family and friends.
  • Notably, jewellery ranks as the number top gift category for coupled-up individuals on China’s romantic days.
  • Traditional gifts like flowers, personal care items, and beauty products remain favorites and “gift boxes” persist as a preference for consumers on seasonal occasions.
  • “Love-brain” (恋爱脑) has recently emerged as a trending term online. It centers on the idea that individuals often lose their emotional or financial rationality when in love. This phenomenon prompted the creation of the phrase “scolding to cure love brain” (骂醒恋爱脑) as a response. And in turn, this has sparked a new type of service.

LINK: https://jingdaily.com/posts/decoding-s-china-s-usd170-billion-romance-economy

4. Xiaohongshu: Unlock new opportunities in Chinese beauty market

Customers are getting more connected to Chinese culture and caring about value, which makes domestic beauty brands more popular. Younger consumers are stepping up as key players in the domestic beauty market.

  • Emergence of quality Chinese cosmetics: Domestic beauty annual sales surged around 10%, outperforming foreign cosmetics with a commanding market share of 50%.
  • Co-create content with the brands: Hundreds of celebrities and top KOLs embarked on the offline and online collaboration with a lot of brands.
  • Create a personalized IP Matrix: Xiaohongshu collaborated with more influential media like CCTV network and created more personalized IP/topics for brands.

LINK: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/4oAwT-Q0mtbWHGQtRYSPLg

5.ByteDance surprises AI rivals with ultra-low cost Doubao model:

  • ByteDance has surprised the artificial intelligence industry with the ultra-low cost of its Doubao model
  • The company said it is capable of processing 2 million Chinese characters, equivalent to 1.25 million tokens, for RMB 1 ($0.14).
  • OpenAI’s most advanced multimodal model, GPT-4o, also unveiled this week, comes in at $5 per million input tokens handled.

LINK:https://technode.com/2024/05/16/bytedance-surprises-ai-rivals-with-ultra-low-cost-doubao-model/

6. Which fashion campaigns for China’s 520 Day hit the mark?

  • Luxury fashion campaigns for China’s 520 Day focus on limited edition collections, celebrity endorsements, and creative storytelling, often in the form of mini videos.
  • Brands like Gucci and Saint Laurent tapped into Gen Z’s preferences by incorporating traditional Chinese elements and leveraging digital platforms for greater engagement.
  • 520 Day’s fusion of traditional Chinese culture with commercialism highlights the evolving landscape of celebrations and consumer behavior, emphasizing the importance of cultural resonance and meaningful experiences in luxury marketing strategies for brands looking to better connect with consumers.
  • These strategies aimed to blend cultural significance with contemporary marketing, enhance brand appeal and foster emotional connections with consumers.

LINK: https://jingdaily.com/posts/which-fashion-campaigns-for-china-s-520-day-hit-the-mark

7. 2024 May Day Holiday: The rise of small cities tourism and AI companions

  • Amid an economy yet to fully recover to pre-pandemic levels, this year’s May Day break underscores a notable trend towards tourism in lesser-known destinations.
  • On social media platforms like Xiaohongshu (RED), many young people are keen to explore counties and even aim to ‘visit Top 100 Counties of China’ as a novel approach to May Day travel.
  • Hong Kong has shifted its focus to cultural and artistic events, as well as large-scale concerts.
  • It is also worth mentioning Japan. With the Yen reaching a 34-year low against the US dollar during the holiday period, this made it more attractive for overseas tourists.
  • ‘AI companion’ emerged as a new trend in travel. This involves using AI technology to offer personalised travel assistance services, crafting tailored itineraries and services.

LINK:https://daoinsights.com/opinions/2024-may-day-holiday-the-rise-of-small-cities-tourism-and-ai-companions/

Latest News on China’s Market

1. Estée Lauder taps Asia’s male beauty market with Manchester United partnership

  • Beauty and skincare giant Estée Lauder has inked an exclusive partnership deal with Manchester United in hopes of tapping the club’s fans in China and the Asia Pacific region.

  • In China alone, the men’s beauty market was projected to surpass $10 billion in 2022 and could reach $33.4 billion (240 billion RMB) by 2027.

  • Most male consumers may be relatively new to the skincare game, especially when it comes to premium products.

  • In the first half of 2023, the GMV of men’s makeup on Douyin surged by 364.6 percent year-on-year. With this market being especially open to beauty and grooming, we’d bet that a clever campaign could work wonders.

LINK: https://jingdaily.com/estee-lauder-manchester-united-collab-male-beauty/

 

2. Male beauty’s next growth engine: Douyin

  • In the first half of 2023, the gross merchandise value (GMV) of men’s makeup sold via Douyin surged 365 percent year on year – Tmall and Taobao combined achieved 6.7 percent growth in the same period.

  • Chinese male beauty brands are quickly expanding on the short video app. Domestic labels claimed seven spots on Douyin’s top 10 best-selling mens’ skin care list, whereas international brands took three places.

  • Male skincare buyers’ profiles: Last year, 70 percent of men’s beauty purchases were made by women, according to a 2022 report from Xiaohongshu. But male buyers have caught up, now accounting for half of male cosmetics purchasers on Douyin.

  • The average age of the male makeup user is between 18 and 30 with an average price of $9.7 (69.2 RMB), significantly lower than on other platforms like Tmall and JD.com.

  • Cooperating with KOLs has proven to be a quick and effective strategy for businesses that want to scale up brand awareness. These influencers are crucial for spreading knowledge about beauty routines.

LINK: https://jingdaily.com/male-beautys-next-growth-engine-douyin/

 

3. McKinsey: Chinese consumers, brands ‘cautiously optimistic’ on tourism and spending

  • Chinese consumers are looking for better deals and sales across platforms like Douyin and Pinduoduo, where products are often sold for “half or less” than on more established competitor shopping apps.

  • McKinsey found that while many remained loyal to their favorite brands, 47 percent of respondents reported switching retailers to obtain a “lower price/discount.”

  • Travel, restaurants and apparel were the top categories consumers were spending on, the survey revealed.

  • However, international travel in June was still 58 percent lower than pre-pandemic levels, though the number of outbound flights from China is “rising rapidly.”

LINK: https://jingdaily.com/mckinsey-report-cautiously-optimistic-tourism-spending/

 

4. China ecological transition: a green revolution led by consumers

  • Keeping balance between satisfying the demand of country’s market, while preserving sustainable standards is challenging

  • Chinese consumers are demonstrating a higher attention to environmental issues compared to the previous years, this trend being reflected in several factors, from carbon emissions to locally produced goods.

  • In this sense, the pandemic has represented a turning point for the development of this trend inside consumer’s mindset, many of which are now willing to pay more for environmentally friendly products.

  • Case study of KFC:  Thanks to “Exploring Carbon Reduction” and “The Journey to Carbon Neutrality” initiatives, introduced in their super App, KFC carried out a green rewards program that encourages consumers to not use disposable cutlery, favor in-store pickup, engage in waste sorting, etc.

LINK: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/HBf_m9WBZ2izfmQNFgOlvg

 

5. Pink burgers, platform Crocs and Malibu dream houses: Barbie’s global collab craze

  • Resale site StockX reported to Jing Daily it had seen more sales of Barbie products in July 2023 than any other month in the company’s history, double sales in July 2022.

  • Among so many names jumping onboard, from Vans, Kipling and Gap, to Pacsun and Nyx, one breaking through the Barbie collaboration noise online is Zara. The Spanish retailer launched a collection on July 21 (the movie release date) inspired by the fashion seen on screen, including a gingham dress, silk pajamas, and other clothing and accessories items

  • Though Zara, Vans, Nike’s Dunk Low sneaker, and Chanel’s themed efforts with the movie all made their way onto social media in China, the clothing and accessories collection from local fashion brand D’izzit is trending in the mainland.

  • Barbie mania is reaching all corners of commerce, from fashion all the way through to luxury hospitality. The W Hotel in Osaka, Japan, is one that’s proven a hit among netizens.

  • Thanks to Barbie nostalgia being at an all-time high, the IP’s pulling power feels unbeatable. Some consumers might be all pinked out, but this is definitely not the end of Barbiecore.

LINK: https://jingdaily.com/barbies-global-collab-craze/

Unleashing the Pulse of China’s Market: Updates and Breaking News.

 

  1. JD launches vertical AI model, targets retail, finance and education sectors:

  • Context: Beijing currently is home to approximately half of the more than 80 large models available in China
  • JD on Thursday introduced its own large AI model ChatRhino. Positioned as a vertical AI model that offers industry-specific use cases, JD’s AI offering arrives a few months later than rivals Alibaba and Baidu. 
  • Why it matters: JD is the latest Chinese tech major attempting to upgrade its offerings with AI and large models. The company said ChatRhino combines 70% generalized data and 30% native intelligent supply chain data, targeting a number of sectors including retail, finance, education, and government.  
  • Details: The company has already utilized the AI model to enhance customer service, facilitate code writing, and improve product recommendations, she added.

JD’s healthcare unit also unveiled a specialized model designed for the medical industry that is capable of quickly adapting and learning from various healthcare scenarios, which will serve as a technological foundation for remote medical services. The e-commerce giant also showcased its ambition to develop humanoid robots, which will be a key exploration direction for the JD Explore Academy.

LINK:
https://technode.com/2023/07/14/jd-launches-vertical-ai-model-targets-retail-finance-and-education-sectors/

 

 

 

2. Baidu AI products overseas

 

The AI social products “SynClub” by Baidu have recently been introduced in Hong Kong, China, Japan, and other countries. This product uses the latest AI technology of Baidu, so that users can know their own AI friends, and through the company of AI friends, users can chat more interestingly and in-depth.

 

3. The “channel retrieval” feature was introduced by the channel.

 

On July 12, the channel launched the “channel retrieval” function for the certification body to support the recovery of the lost agency authentication channel.

It is understood that “channel retrieval” refers to the channel that has completed enterprise and institutional certification or main body verification and can initiate the channel retrieval process and re-operate the channel after the platform verifies the authenticity of the main body.

In the process of initiating the retrieval, it is necessary to pay attention to the following two points: First, the initiator has not created a channel, and it is necessary to use a wechat signal that has not created a channel to initiate the retrieval process. Second, the account must be in normal use, and the account that has been cancelled, blocked, or banned cannot be recovered.

 

 

 

4. Users of the Meituan app can now record and upload brief videos.

 

Meituan has unveiled a new feature on its app that now allows users to shoot and upload short videos. The addition of this feature provides users with more creative ways to engage with the platform and record their experiences.

Meituan’s latest move comes amidst the intensifying rivalry with Douyin within the online local services industry.

The food delivery giant has also made moves to shake up the live-streaming business by hosting more live-streaming events, including monthly live streams on the 18th of each month since April, where participants are offered coupons.

In addition, the company launched its very own platform, Meituan Live, which is currently only visible to a select group.

Meituan continues to evolve as a multifaceted platform in order to stay competitive in the market

LINK: https://daoinsights.com/news/meituan-app-now-supports-users-to-shoot-and-upload-short-videos/

 

 

 

5. China’s newest beauty retail battleground, Douyin, was won by L’Oreal by 1 billion RMB.

 

L’Oréal topped a ranking of brand sales in the first half of the year, hitting a GMV of 1 billion RMB 

Douyin is the nation’s newest retail battleground, and international brands are actively fighting to grow their market share for Gen Z

Social platforms like Douyin are becoming pivotal channels for brands to close the loop in digital commerce

L’Oréal collaborates with roughly 800 to 1,500 Douyin KOLs every month, ranging from mega influencers with over 5 million followers to small-to-medium key opinion consumers

LINK:
https://jingdaily.com/loreal-douyin-china-newest-beauty-retail-battleground-billion-rmb-gmv/

 

 

 

6. Three New WeChat Advertisement Products Online Now

 

Moments Ads brand gallery: advertisement is WeChat’s first vertical multi-screen display advertisement. It supports 3-5 vertical screen video cards displayed at the same time, and the new method of display brings an eye-catching visual experience by creating a high-level window texture for the brand and enhancing the user’s memory of the brand.

WeChat Channels Carousel Ads: advertising supports 3-5 components, which are displayed on large tiles throughout the process. Different cards can be diverted to different official mini programs or different pages of mini programs, or they can be turned to native pages and H5. 

WeChat Search: discovering brand surprises through WeChat Search and finding beautiful gifts for their loved ones for Qixi Festival

LINK:

https://www.luxurysociety.com/en/articles/2023/07/what-should-luxury-expect-post-pandemic-chinese-travellers 

 

 

 

7. Translation vs Transcreation: which one is the right choice?

 

When expanding a business to a new country with linguistic and cultural differences, it’s crucial to ensure that the brand’s message and identity are accurately conveyed to the new audience.

Translation is the process of converting text from one language to another while preserving the original meaning, making it suitable for more literal texts. Transcreation, on the other hand, is a creative approach that adapts the message, cultural nuances, and persuasiveness to resonate with the target audience.

Factors such as the purpose of the text, marketing strategy, target market, and time/budget constraints should be considered when deciding between translation and transcreation for a successful linguistic adaptation.

LINK:

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/meZQ7MC_HIHktV-0KSPdhg 

 

 

8. How AI technology is reshaping beauty retail in China

 

Store of the Future on Shanghai’s East Nanjing Road The first of its kind in China, the new concept retail space boasts seven digital touchpoints: an advanced skin analysis device powered by big data; a product recommendation feature based on AI-generated makeup trends; product labels equipped with radio frequency identification (RFID) that unlock a detailed breakdown of ingredients; mobile POS, which allows customers to check out anywhere with a beauty advisor and avoid long queues; and personalized gift packages with the option to add scents and voice messages.

Meanwhile, the Shanghai Municipal Medical Products Administration has granted SkinCeuticals, Estée Lauder, L’Oréal, and Shanghai Chuangyuan Cosmetics stores in Shanghai a license for personalized on-site services. With this license, retail stores can act as mini cosmetic factories, creating products tailored to individual skin types.

Typically, consumers seek the advice of sales assistants or search for product reviews by influencers.  plus the fact that KOLs and personal shoppers may have other motives for recommending certain items (e.g., brand sponsorships).

When stepping into the futuristic concept store, customers are asked to use their WeChat account to sign into the AI experience. Users are then connected personally to a salesperson who helps them through their purchase journey in person and can stay in touch with them once they leave the store.

 

 

What’s happening in the Chinese market

China’s answer to ChatGPT? Baidu shares tumble as Ernie Bot disappoints

The introduction of Ernie coincides with Google and Microsoft upping their AI game. As the CEO of Baidu makes brief video presentations in which he makes it abundantly clear that the AI still needs many improvements, Baidu shares fall.

Analysts claim it was a staged event with pre-recorded videos of the test and showcases, proving they were hesitant to perform it live. As a result, rumors claim it is not yet operational (Baidu stock fell by 6% following the presentation).

The public still cannot access AI. Ernie is able to create images and videos, speak and understand various Chinese dialects, write poetry, and perform math.

https://www.reuters.com/technology/chinese-search-giant-baidu-introduces-ernie-bot-2023-03-16/

 

Top Chinese PR agency to replace copywriters and designers with ChatGPT-like tech

Since securing Microsoft as a client, BlueFocus, which was ranked first among its Chinese peers and 11th overall among public relations firms worldwide in 2022, has made significant investments in AI. The company has also worked with Chinese ChatGPT substitutes, such as Baidu’s Ernie Bot, for use in online persona development and other forms of digital marketing.

It will do away with outside copywriters, designers, and temporary workers in favor of generative AI like ChatGPT. Up to one-fourth of current work could be replaced by ChatGPT-like technology, particularly in the fields of office administration and legal services.

https://hr.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/industry/top-chinese-pr-agency-to-replace-copywriters-designers-with-chatgpt-like-tech/99470589

 

Notice on the Compliance of WeChat Official Account Marketing Content

The Measures for the Administration of Internet Advertising were recently released by the Market Supervision of China and will go into effect on May 1.

The official account operators, who advertise goods or services in various ways and include shopping links and other ways to make purchases, are, in my opinion, the most crucial factor for us. The term “advertisement” needs to be clearly identified.

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/R6FoptfmnOiLZPFMTh2uLw

 

A 80 year old grandmother be MIUMIU brand ambassador

When choosing an ambassador, many brands today, particularly luxury brands or high-end new consumer brands, are edging closer to middle-aged and older artists and models.
This 80-year-old grandmother appeared in a Miu Miu fashion advertisement.

In contrast to earlier fashion posters From the posters, we can sense the appeal of the past and another interpretation of fashion.

In order to reach a wider audience and draw in more young customers, brands like Lululemon are starting to favor middle-aged and elderly spokespersons. Fashion does not only belong to young people; it is about exploring individual fashion attitudes at any age.

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Lr4XlQiekcj7ALMhXDVAJA

 

Xiaohongshu decodes the urban core fashion trend through the sports market in Shanghai

Xiaohongshu visited a sports market in Shanghai over the May Day weekend that was showcasing the new fashion craze Urbancore. Participating brands and fashion KOLs organized a variety of outdoor sporting events, capitalizing on China’s enduring fitness craze to increase engagement.

In order to promote participation, a number of live streams with giveaways and prizes of urbancore-inspired clothing were combined with the offline market.

Xiaohongshu decodes Urbancore fashion trend through sports market in Shanghai

 

Xiaohongshu to launch group buying function

This is the most recent action taken by Xiaohongshu to expand her reach in the “local life” market.

Xiaohongshu has been working to strengthen the link between online peer-to-peer recommendation and offline services in users’ local areas ever since the launch of the “Nearby” feed in 2019. Consumers can be encouraged to spend money locally by offering discounts for group purchases, which must be made.

Online group buying penetration in China was only 12.7% in 2021, and this number is only anticipated to rise, creating an untapped market.

Xiaohongshu to launch group buying function

 

China’s May Day Holiday Reveals New Favorite Tourist Destinations

The price of admission to scenic areas increased 1,000% from the same time last year, exceeding pre-pandemic levels. From April 17 to May 7, Macau was the most popular travel destination for Chinese tourists in Asia, a 32 percent decline from visits to Hong Kong.

Other than these well-known tourist destinations, obscure places saw growth over the holiday. Particularly for its inexpensive barbecue food and good value for money experiences, Zibo has become extremely popular on social media. May Day hotel bookings soared 800 percent from 2019.

Labor Day saw an all-time high in international excursion bookings on Fliggy, more than tripling the previous record set during this year’s Spring Festival. However, the number of available international flights continues to restrict travel abroad.

https://jingdaily.com/tencent-douyin-content-agreement-copyright/

 

For Marketers, Does It Even Matter If It’s Not Real?

Luxury brands are embracing the concept of “virtual luxury” more and more in order to appeal to younger, digitally savvy consumers who value sustainability and one-of-a-kind experiences. To engage customers and create fresh opportunities for brand interaction, this entails using virtual experiences and products.

But the question still stands: Is authenticity still important in marketing? While virtual luxury might be alluring in the short term, brands shouldn’t discount the value of authenticity and quality when fostering long-term consumer trust and loyalty.

Given these trends, luxury brands should think about how to strike a balance between the advantages of virtual luxury and the requirement to uphold a strong brand identity and reputation. This might entail coming up with inventive ways to combine tangible goods and services with digital ones, all the while upholding the brand’s commitment to excellence and authenticity throughout.

https://www.luxurysociety.com/en/articles/2023/04/marketers-does-it-even-matter-if-its-not-real

Chinese Marketing Updates

TikTok Parent ByteDance Battles Meta for Virtual-Reality App Developers

Developers who created virtual reality software for Meta Platforms are being offered payment by ByteDance Ltd. to port their programs to its rapidly expanding Pico headset line.

After experiencing lengthy delays in receiving distribution approval, some software developers have expressed frustration with the way Meta is reviewing new applications for its Quest headsets. Some developers claim that the business’s procedures lack precise guidelines, leaving them to eagerly anticipate the entry of new rivals. 

ByteDance acquired Pico, a B2B-focused company, in 2021 and changed its focus to B2C. Currently, the Pico 4 headset performs worse than the Meta headset and has a much smaller selection of games (300 vs. 500).

https://www.wsj.com/articles/tiktok-parent-bytedance-battles-meta-for-virtual-reality-app-developers-30ce091f

 

An interesting “mini” marketing strategy for the brand

 

The milk tea company “Diandian” has introduced the Earth Day mini cup to celebrate World Earth Day:

McDonald’s mini cone, DQ mini ice cream, and a Wuling small car that popularized the mini model have all used mini marketing to successfully penetrate various product markets.

Creating products that are larger than conventional, creating visual impact, and raising traffic topics when consumers are tired of brand and product cognition.Meet the market’s demand and expectations for weight loss, lightweight, and burden free products.

For current consumers, lightweight consumption and cute design in various aspects have become undeniable market trends, and product miniaturization is the simplest way to approach the trend.

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/R6FoptfmnOiLZPFMTh2uLw.  

 

Galeries Lafayette teams up with Hopson Group for luxury expansion in China

 

The new partnership aims to open ten stores in China by 2025. Future stores will carry independent Chinese designer brands in addition to well-known international ones.  

In order to convey “a certain vision of the French art of living in the heart of unique and selective multi-brand environments,” the joint venture will also concentrate on selling luxury brands in their upscale stores.

Through the partnership, both parties will be able to leverage their individual strengths to build a cutting-edge high-end department store company with a world-class buyer team and cutting-edge supply chain management system. 

Overall, the new partnership between Galeries Lafayette and Hopson Group marks a significant advancement in China’s luxury retail market. 

https://daoinsights.com/news/galeries-lafayette-teams-up-with-hopson-group-for-luxury-expansion-in-china/

 

Rivals Tencent Video and Douyin Reach Content-Sharing Agreement After Copyright Spat

 

Both parties have formally agreed to support content sharing, enabling users of Tencent’s well-known TV dramas to access them through the Douyin app without violating copyright. This is an intriguing development in the competition between China’s video and live-streaming apps, which are increasingly popular among Chinese consumers as tools for shopping and entertainment.

The collaboration may be an example of putting differences aside for the benefit of developing China’s tech and social media sectors. In the long run, it might also draw more users to the platforms.

https://jingdaily.com/tencent-douyin-content-agreement-copyright/

 

How Luxury Brands Are Courting the New Chinese Consumer As Shopping Tourism Resumes

Luxury brands are utilizing a variety of digital strategies, including e-commerce, social media, and live streaming, to connect with China’s extremely tech-savvy consumers. 

Personalized shopping experiences are created by luxury brands in collaboration with travel agencies as part of their key strategy for appealing to Chinese consumers.

By providing immersive, experiential shopping opportunities like in-store events and pop-ups, luxury brands are also leveraging the growth of the “experience economy.”

With features like personalized recommendations and augmented reality try-ons, Alibaba’s Tmall Luxury Pavilion and Luxury Soho platforms are playing an increasingly significant role in connecting luxury brands with Chinese consumers.

Additionally, luxury brands are taking action to address Chinese consumers’ concerns about sustainability and ethics in their marketing and business practices.

https://www.alizila.com/how-luxury-brands-court-chinese-consumers-shopping-tourism-travel-alibaba-lvmh-richemont/

 

Latest Updates on China’s Market: ByteDance’s Language Model, Uncle Stars, Xiaohongshu Trends, Douyin’s PC Shopping, and More

ByteDance to emphasize search and imaging as it develops ChatGPT’s rival

 

ByteDance, the owner of TikTok, has assembled a sizable language model team and plans to integrate the technology into its search and advertising businesses as the hype surrounding ChatGPT, an AI-powered chatbot service, continues to encourage Chinese businesses to create analogous products of their own.

When ByteDance launches its large language model, which is anticipated to happen in the middle of this year, it will put a particular emphasis on language and imaging. 

The large language model team and the image model team will be managed by Zhu Wenjia, head of global search and development for TikTok. 

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/pGREeoSC6v-tf2zALdWZBQ

 

The Rise Of China’s ‘Uncle Stars’: How Middle-aged Men Are Taking The Spotlight

 

Idol scandals have tarnished China’s entertainment sector in recent years. 

As was the case with Louis Vuitton and rapper Kris Wu, luxury brands associated with wrongdoing (“little fresh meat”) were forced to act quickly to sever their endorsement agreements in order to allay public outrage.

People in their mid-forties, also referred to as “uncle stars,” provide a safer option for brands and have a wider market recognition among both young and old consumers. 

Brands are testing a new cast of ambassadors due to the expensive unpredictability of “traffic stars,” who heavily rely on the fan economy to push the sales of the products they promote. 

Huang Bo, a 48-year-old actor, was named the ambassador for Shiseido’s high-end line on February 9.  

These celebrities typically don’t have Xiaohongshu or Douyin, only Weibo. “By making extra efforts, brands need to increase their influence,

https://jingdaily.com/china-uncle-stars-middle-aged-men-ambassadors-shiseido-fresh-the-knockout/ 

 

2023 Xiaohongshu Annual Life Trend Analysis

 

To observe and research young people’s lifestyles, Xiaohongshu and the Institute of Sociology, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, published the “2023 Life Trends” report with the theme “Into Real Life.” 

The report divides various life keywords, identifies, and analyzes life trends in 2023 using Xiaohongshu’s data statistics and topic content from the previous year. An excerpt from the report is given below. 

Warming up the neighborhood: Due to the scarcity of supplies during the epidemic, many residents got to know their neighbors by searching for those who lived “nearby” to shop with and trade goods with. Young people are therefore more likely to actively participate in community activities.

Eat authentically local flavors: Young people are starting to prefer regional specialties and regional traditions, 

  • On a trip: Due to the extended stays at home brought on by the epidemic, many people seek compensatory travel in the new year. They value the chance to travel more and are prepared to spend more effort, time, and money on travel.
  • Stress relief: Due to environmental impact, the majority of people felt helpless and unable to control their destiny, so they needed to decompress quickly and easily. Simple techniques for stress relief have become more popular in recent years.

Overall, investing and participating in real life will be more popular in 2023. The new trend among young people today will be actively experiencing and pursuing an innovative life, which is also Xiaohongshu’s wish for 2023 in this report.

https://www.chinatradingdesk.com/post/2023-xiaohongshu-annual-life-trend-analysis

 

Douyin tests out PC shopping feature to boost e-commerce

 

Douyin, a popular video-sharing website in China, is currently testing a PC shopping feature that will let users have a similar shopping experience to that of its mobile app.

The live broadcast room on Douyin’s website now features a product mounting function that enables users to view available products right away. However, direct orders and payments are still not supported on the PC version of the live streams. 

Users must scan the code with their Douyin app before they can finish their purchases. 

https://daoinsights.com/news/douyin-tests-out-pc-shopping-feature/

 

Xiaohongshu doubles down on social networking with group chat feature 

 

Users can access the new feature under the “group chat” drop-down menu accessible from the Messages tab on the app. Here, users have the option of starting a brand-new group chat or going to the “group chat plaza,” where they can peruse various discussions in a grid format.  

Users can join group chats on Xiaohongshu with just one click, unlike private Facebook groups where they must submit a request to join and have it approved by an admin.  

Users will have the chance to create communities to connect over specific interests thanks to the new feature. Influencers and retailers also profit from the new feature because the buzz created in group chats can boost traffic to their profiles and aid in turning that traffic into sales. 

https://daoinsights.com/news/xiaohongshu-doubles-down-on-social-networking-with-group-chat-feature/ 

 

China’s Tourism Rebound Faces a Roadblock: A Lack of Travel Agents

 

Some predicted a “big bang” for the global tourism industry when China abandoned its “zero-COVID” regulations as Chinese tourists flocked abroad.

Millions of Chinese tourists are eager to resume their international travel. But the tourism sector isn’t prepared for them.

The number of people leaving China increased to 676,000 on February 6 when outbound package tours resumed, which is the highest number in three years but only about one-third of the pre-pandemic levels. 

In many cases, travelers are prepared to return to foreign countries, but travel agencies are not. 

Currently, there aren’t many options for outbound group tours, and most of them are quite expensive. Rebuilding the international teams and the supply chain takes time.

Chinese tourists still favor joining group tours over planning their own trips.

https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1012339/chinas-tourism-rebound-faces-a-roadblock-a-lack-of-travel-agents?source=channel_deep